Appendix:
Guidelines for Referees
Yes | No | N/A | See comments | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Is the subject matter suitable for publication in The Western Australian Naturalist? | ||||
Is the Title appropriate? | ||||
Does the Abstract cover the important findings in the paper? | ||||
Does the Introduction provide an appropriate background? | ||||
Are the Methods appropriate? | ||||
Are the Results/Observations clearly presented? | ||||
Does the Discussion place the results/observations into context? | ||||
Is the statistical analysis appropriate? | ||||
Are all the Tables appropriate and necessary? | ||||
Are all the Figures appropriate and necessary? | ||||
Are the References appropriate and necessary? | ||||
Does the nomenclature follow accepted current usage? |
Overall assessment:
Accept | |
Modifications needed | .. |
Reject |
Name (optional) …………………………………………………………………… Date: ……………………
Additional comments: